COURT OF APPEAL ALAIN BEAUDOIN, BRENT SMITH, JOHN KOOPMAN, JOHN VAN MUYEN, RIVERSIDE CALVARY CHAPEL, IMMANUEL COVENANT

The Appellants’ Treatment of the Evidence ....................................................11 The Appellants Mischaracterize the Evidence ..............................................11 The Appellants Provide Lay Opinion Evidence .............................................13 The Appellants Rely on Extra-Record Evidence ...........................................13 VI. [...] The chambers judge correctly confined the record to the “record of proceeding” .....................................................................................15 The Affidavits of Dr. [...] 51 of the PHA.9 The Notice of Regional Event triggered the PHO’s authority under the PHA to exercise emergency powers, including the power to issue orders respecting “health hazards”.10 Each of the 1 Appellants’ Factum (“AF”) at para. [...] The more people there were in a space, and the smaller the size of the space, the greater the risk that droplets carrying the virus would be inhaled by other people.14 6. [...] The February 10, 2021 order was the order in effect at the time of the hearing before the chambers judge.